|
Introduction
This
report describes the results from the 1997 Regional Monitoring Program
for Trace Substances (RMP). It is the fifth annual report from the
RMP which began in 1993 and includes data, interpretation, and synthesis
from Base Program monitoring, as well as results of pilot and special
studies conducted or completed in 1997. Additionally, this report
includes several articles contributed by some RMP investigators
and other researchers. These articles provide perspective and insight
on important contaminant issues identified by the RMP, and they
describe results from projects that took advantage of RMP field
operations. Background information about the RMP, included in previous
Annual Reports, is not repeated in this report. Instead, the reader
is referred to those reports where appropriate. A
full description of the RMP is also included in the RMP Program
Plan available from the San Francisco Estuary Institute (SFEI) and
through our website at http://www.sfei.org.
In
1997, the list of Program Participants was expanded to seventy-seven
federal, state, and local agencies and companies. Together with
the San Francisco Bay
Regional Water Quality Control Board (Regional Board), they
participated in the RMP as funders and service providers. They also
assist in directing the Program through input or participation on
the Steering and Technical Review Committees. The RMP
Participants are listed on the inside of the front cover.
RMP
Objectives
Staff
at the Regional Board and SFEI along with representatives of RMP
participating agencies developed the Program objectives:
1. Obtain
high quality baseline data describing the concentrations of
toxic and potentially toxic trace elements and organic contaminants
in the water and sediment of the San Francisco Estuary.
2. Determine
seasonal and annual trends in chemical and biological water
quality in the San Francisco Estuary.
3. Continue
to develop a data set that can be used to determine long-term
trends in the concentrations of toxic and potentially toxic
trace elements and organic contaminants in the water and sediments
of the San Francisco Estuary.
4. Determine
whether water and sediment quality in the Estuary at large are
in compliance with objectives established by the Basin Plan.
5. Provide
a data base on water and sediment quality in the Estuary which
is compatible with data being developed in other ongoing studies
in the system, including, but not limited to, wasteload allocation
studies and model development, sediment quality objectives development,
in-bay studies of dredged material disposal, Interagency Ecological
Program (IEP) water quality studies, primary productivity studies,
local effects biomonitoring programs, and state and federal
mussel watch programs.
Monitoring
Design
The
RMP sampling design was based on the Bay
Protection and Toxic Cleanup Program (BPTCP) Pilot Studies developed
by the Regional Board (Flegal et al., 1994). The reasoning behind
the original design, with stations located along the †spineÿ of
the Estuary, was to include stations that, in a long-term monitoring
program, would indicate spatial and temporal trends in toxicity
and chemistry, determine background concentrations for different
reaches of the Estuary, and assess whether there were high levels
of contaminants or toxicity. Several new stations were added in
1994 to fill spatial gaps and to begin monitoring near major tributaries
(SFEI, 1995). Additionally, two stations were added in 1994 in the
southern-most end of the Estuary in cooperation with the Cities
of San Jose (station C-3-0) and Sunnyvale (station C-1-3) and the
Regional Board as part of their National Pollutant Discharge Elimination
System (NPDES) monitoring.
The
RMP station design has provided a picture of the range of conditions
found in deeper parts of the Estuary, influenced by riverine, seasonal,
and daily natural processes. During the re-design process, options
for incorporating more near-shore stations, evaluating overall Estuary
condition at statistically representative sites, or conducting intensive
embayment studies will be explored.
Five
types of samples were collected in the 1997 Base Program:
1. Conventional
water quality and chemistry.
2. Aquatic
bioassays.
3. Sediment
quality and chemistry.
4. Sediment
bioassays.
5. Transplanted,
bagged bivalve bioaccumulation, survival, and condition.
Complete
listings of all parameters measured in 1997 are included in Table
1.1. Methods of collection and analysis are detailed in Appendix
A. RMP data included in this report can be obtained by contacting
SFEI or by accessing SFEIπs website at: http://www.sfei.org.
Locations
of the twenty-two RMP and two Southern Slough (C-3-0, C-1-3) sampling
stations are shown in the RMP station
location map; Table 1.2 lists
the station names, codes, locations, and sampling dates for all
1997 stations. Water, sediment, or bioaccumulation sampling sites
with the same station name may have different station codes as they
are situated at slightly different locations (latitude, longitude)
due to practical considerations such as sediment type or ability
to deploy bivalves. For example, at the South Bay site BA20 is the
water station code and BA21 is the sediment station code.
Sampling
occurred during three periods in 1997: during the wet season (JanuaryFebruary),
a period of declining Delta outflow (late April), and during the
dry season (JulyAugust). The rationale for taking seasonal ¯snapshots”
is to relate contaminant data during hydrologically different periods
of the year with higher-frequency measurements conducted by the
U.S. Geological Survey and to evaluate the influence of natural
variability on the contaminant signal. As part of the RMP re-design,
the use of more intensive data on tides, Delta outflow, salinity
gradients, algal blooms, and other parameters will be evaluated
in greater detail to minimize the natural noise around any signals
of water quality improvement or degradation over time.
Not
all parameters were measured at all RMP stations each sampling period.
Sampling activities at each station are listed on Table
1.2. Water samples were collected at all stations during all
three sampling periods; however, trace organic contaminants in water
were only measured at eighteen RMP stations and at San Jose (C-3-0).
Aquatic bioassays were conducted at eight RMP stations and at Sunnyvale
and San Jose (C-1-3 and C-3-0) during the wet- and dry-season sampling
periods.
Sediment
sampling was conducted during the wet- and dry-season sampling periods
only. Sediment samples were collected from all RMP stations, except
the Golden Gate station (BC20, this site is very deep). Sediment
toxicity was measured at fourteen RMP stations and at San Jose (C-3-0)
during the wet- and dry-season sampling periods. Measurements of
ammonia and sulfides in sediment were also conducted in 1997 to
support interpretation of sediment toxicity data.
Bivalve
trace metal bioaccumulation was measured at eleven RMP stations,
bivalve trace organic bioaccumulation was measured at fourteen RMP
stations, and bivalve survival and condition was measured at thirteen
RMP stations during the wet- and dry-season sampling periods.
Water
and sediment samples were collected from the R/V David Johnston
chartered through the University of California, Santa Cruz. Each
sampling cruise starts with water sampling at all RMP stations.
Sediment sampling is then conducted with a separate run though the
Estuary. Each complete sampling run requires three to five days.
Bivalve monitoring consisted of three parts: deployment of transplants
from reference sites, maintenance, and retrieval. Most of this work
was conducted aboard the R/V Questuary, owned by San Francisco State
University. The California Department of Water Resources provided
back-up services for bivalve cruises.
As
in past years, field sampling and laboratory analysis were coordinated
by the RMP prime contractor, Applied Marine Sciences in Livermore,
California. In addition, a group of Principal Investigators also
participated in the RMP (Table 1.3).
References
Flegal,
A.R., R.W. Risebrough, B. Anderson, J. Hunt, S. Anderson, J.
Oliver, M. Stephenson, and R.Packard. 1994. San Francisco Estuary
Pilot Regional Monitoring Program: Sediment Studies. San Francisco
Bay Regional Water Quality Control Board, State Water Resources
Control Board.
SFEI.
1995. 1994 Annual Report: San Francisco Estuary Regional Monitoring
Program for Trace Substances. Prepared by the San Francisco
Estuary Institute, Oakland, CA. 339p.
|